Penn Badgley rang in his birthday with his very own face cake. In honor of turning 35 on Nov. 1, his wife Domino Kirke ordered a cake with one of his characters on it. No, it wasn’t Dan Humphrey from Gossip Girl. In a series of Instagram Stories shared on Tuesday, Domino gave everyone a glimpse of the You-themed baked good, which was in the shape of the number 35 and had photos of Penn’s You character Joe Goldberg all over. “I love eating my husbands face,” Domino captioned the Story. The cake was also decorated in all kinds of sweet treats including berries, pomegranate seeds, flowers, figs, gold flakes, and macarons. Something tells us Love Quinn would be proud of this bakery item! See more pictures of Penn’s You birthday cake ahead.